This Kathy Shaidle post had me laughing first and thinking deeply second. For those of you in the Peanut Gallery who haven't been paying attention, it's election day in Canada and the ruling Liberals are on their last legs, being down by about 10% in the polls this weekend.
Borrowing from Mark 9 and/or Matthew 17, Shaidle's Election Day post is headlined "This kind [of demon] does not go out except by prayer and fasting." She continues-
And voting.
But prayer and fasting doesn't hurt.
That's funny, but it's only funny if your ready to spin today's vote as a political exorcism, casting the Martin government as demons. As much as I'm not a fan of the Canadian Liberals, they aren't demons. Probably oppressed by some, but not demons themselves.
There is a unhealthy spirit of corruption in Ottawa that has Ol' Sloughfoot egging it on, but that's in part due to the Liberals being in power for a while. Before folks write that off as some neocon rant, the same could well be said for the modern GOP; Abramoff might well have been more toxic to how Washington was run than the sponsorship scandal and the apparent leaking of a dividend tax cut were to how Ottawa was run.
Yes, there are some differences; the Republicans have been quicker to disown the folks involved in Casinogate than the Liberals were to distance themselves from their bad apples. It's hard for a party to investigate its own bad apples; the tendency is to sweep things under the rug and to give "your guys" the benefit of the doubt. However, that doesn't make either party inherently corrupt; it's power that does the corrupting, and congressional Republicans and parliamentary Liberals have been in power for over a decade.
The Democrats were needed to clean house after Watergate bringing transparency to opaque corruptions of the era. Canadian politics isn't as corrupt as the early-70s US is, but reforms are best done by the opposition. The Conservatives may be the folks to perform the "exorcism" but the demon isn't the Liberals, it's the corrupting effects of power.
The idea of an exorcism to drive out the demon without killing the person being possessed. In this case, the Liberals aren't the demon, they're the people being possessed by the corruption demon. The government isn't some vampire than needs a stake in the heart1, but a patient that needs a cure.
There is an honest case to be made for larger, more compassionate government. There's also an honest case to be made for Canada keeping a proper distance from the US in foreign affairs. There's also an honest case to be made for how federal Canada should be, looking at what should be done on a federal level and what should be done at a provincial level.
I don't see Paul Martin making such honest cases, but a less bombastic/demagogic Liberal leader should be allowed to make those cases in the future without being seen as a demon. Once the Liberals get the current scandals behind them and get new management, they'll be back in position to press those (and other) cases and better contend for power once again.
The other side isn't a demon. We need to remember that. Conservatives on both side of the 49th should remember that tonight and in the days to come. While Conservatives in the north will look to clean up their corruption with a new government, conservatives in the south should work on cleaning house after Casinogate and get back to the spirit of transparency that that Class of '94 came in with. The demon is nontransparent power, and it can strike at any party in power.
1 That metaphor is often used in conservative circles; Rush used to run a series of Count Taxula ads (with his sidekick Algore) at Clinton's expense.
Recent Comments